Select Page

The CEO/COO relationship is one of the most critical dynamics in any business. A great Chief Operating Officer (COO) doesn’t just execute strategy; they act as the bridge between vision and execution, ensuring the company runs smoothly while enabling the CEO to focus on growth and big-picture objectives. However, hiring a COO isn’t just about finding a skilled operator—it’s about finding the right person for your CEO’s leadership style, company culture, and long-term business success.

If you’re a CEO looking for your ideal second-in-command, or if you’re advising one, here’s how to ensure the right fit.

1. Understanding the CEO’s Leadership Style

The best COOs complement their CEOs rather than replicate them. Start by assessing the CEO’s strengths, weaknesses, and working preferences:

Visionary vs. Integrator: Many CEOs are big-picture thinkers with a visionary mindset. If that’s the case, they need a COO who thrives on execution, processes, and operational discipline. This dynamic, often referenced in EOS (Entrepreneurial Operating System) models, ensures the CEO stays focused on growth while the COO handles execution.

High-Involvement vs. Delegator: Some CEOs like to be hands-on in all aspects of the business, while others prefer to delegate. A COO should either balance or reinforce this preference.

Conflict Resolution Style: Does the CEO thrive on debate or prefer consensus-driven leadership? A COO should be able to challenge the CEO when needed but also work in a way that fosters trust.

Before hiring, the CEO should define their leadership style and communication preferences. A simple assessment, such as the Kolbe Index or DISC profile, can help clarify this.

2. Defining the Company Culture and Values

A COO must align with the company’s values, as they will be responsible for embedding these into daily operations. Consider:

Pace of the Organization: Is the company in hyper-growth mode, requiring a COO comfortable with rapid scaling, or is it a more mature company needing stability and refinement?

People vs. Process: Some businesses require a COO with strong people leadership skills, while others need a process-driven operator.

Cultural Fit: The COO will set the tone for leadership. If your company values transparency, agility, or innovation, the COO must embody those qualities.

Pro Tip: Involve key team members in the hiring process to ensure the COO resonates with the existing culture.

3. Clarifying the CEO/COO Dynamic

The CEO and COO need a strong foundation of trust, respect, and clearly defined roles. Before hiring, the CEO should establish:

Decision-Making Authority: Where does the CEO want the COO to take the lead, and where will the CEO remain hands-on?

Communication Cadence: Regular one-on-ones, leadership meetings, and check-ins help maintain alignment.

Key Responsibilities: Will the COO handle internal operations only, or will they also drive external growth initiatives?

4. Prioritizing Business Needs Over Ego

A great COO is someone who fills gaps, not just a yes-person to the CEO. The best CEOs recognize that hiring someone who challenges them can be an asset, not a threat. A few key areas to assess:

Strength in Execution: Can they turn strategy into action without needing micromanagement?

Scalability: Do they have experience leading a company through the next stage of growth?

Operational Expertise: Are they skilled in financial management, process improvement, or team development—whichever areas the business needs most?

5. The Hiring Process: Finding the Right Fit

Once you know the ideal COO profile, follow a structured hiring process:

1. Define Success: Outline key metrics, expectations, and a 90-day roadmap for the role.

2. Leverage Networks: CEOs should tap into their industry connections, private equity groups, or leadership forums to find high-quality candidates.

3. Use Behavioral Interviewing: Ask candidates how they’ve handled specific challenges related to execution, leadership, and working with a CEO.

4. Test Compatibility: Conduct working sessions to see how the CEO and COO interact under pressure.

5. Check References Deeply: Speak with former CEOs, peers, and team members to understand the candidate’s leadership style and effectiveness.

Final Thoughts: The Right COO Drives Long-Term Success

The right COO can be the difference-maker in a company’s ability to scale, innovate, and operate efficiently. However, success hinges on more than just operational skills—it requires alignment with the CEO’s style, company culture, and long-term vision.

By taking a structured approach to hiring and prioritizing compatibility over credentials alone, CEOs can find a COO who will not just execute but truly elevate the business.

Would you like help refining a specific job description or hiring framework for this role? Reach out and let’s chat.